Sunday, May 31, 2020
Diary

Persona 5 Royal: Is This Enhanced Version of P5 Worth Playing?

Persona 5 Royal Opening ScreenPersona 5 Royal Opening Screen

Is it worth revisiting the stylish world of the Phantom Thieves with Persona 5 Royal?


April 2020 is a really dark month throughout the world. But there is still one bright spot. A very bright spot for gamers, and video game tourists, like me.

Persona 5 Royal English Edition is out!

And with that, it’s again time to indulge in the bizarre adventures of “Ren Amamiya,” as well as visit all the events and days left out in the 2017 original.

My First “Expanded” Atlus Game

I bought P5 Royal on release day, and this will be the first time that I’m playing an expanded Atlus game.

Yeah. As much as I love the Persona series, I’ve never agreed with Atlus’ practice of releasing expanded or enhanced version of their bestsellers. FYI, I bought a cheap second-hand copy of P3: FES five years ago and till now, I’ve never even booted the disc. To me, the practice of releasing enhanced editions just reeks of lame money-milking. Why couldn’t Atlus release the original at a higher price but with full contents?

Having read the changes implemented in P5 Royal, though, and with the title still one of my favourite games ever, I decided this might actually be worth it. My mini review below will thus focus on, erm, how “fresh” Persona 5 Royal is for a P5 original player. Is it nostalgic but dreary beyond minutes? Or is it a whole different experience?

Naturally, if you’ve never played the original version, I’d go ahead and tell you to immediately buy P5 Royal. It WILL be one of the best games on your PS4. You don’t know what you’re missing out on.


All screenshots belong to Atlus, naturally!


First Run

To begin with, Wake Up, Get Up, Get Out There has been replaced by Colors Flying High as the opening theme. I … don’t think I’d love this new composition as much as I did for the older one. But it’s still a befitting opening to the game. (And probably would grow on me down the road)

Persona 5 Royal Title Screen.
The reworked title screen. I feel it’s less visually striking compared to the old one, but jazzier and worldlier.
Persona 5 Royal Battle Tutorial.
Tutorial battle! My immediate reaction on seeing this was that the graphics are crispier and more vibrant.

To put it in writing, graphics have (of course) been enhanced. Here’s a great comparison video between the old and the new.

To further go into details, the changes look to include:

  1. Temperature/white balance shifts. From warm palettes to cool ones, or vice versa.
  2. As mentioned above, sharper, richer colours.
  3. Additional environmental details. Definitely more signs and textures, and other cosmetics, in the open-world.
Persona 5 Royal Yongenjaya.
Yongenjaya. I didn’t need to refer to the original game to notice the additional environmental details. Having visited the actual Tokyo district Yongenjaya is based on, I must say I was thrilled to return” to this digital version too.
Persona 5 Royal Shibuya Station Square!
Shibuya Station Square! Now those Sakura blooms are definitely new. Definitely, a fantastic addition to the environment too!

Enough about graphics and open-world environmental changes. Onto cutscenes and new dialogues.

Now, there’s a very obvious new battle dialogue segment right at the start, one that introduces a new character.

Outside of that, though, I haven’t yet encountered anything that feels markedly new. In fact, I originally though the cutscene depicting the discovery of Kamoshida’s Palace had new cuts added to it. On comparison with the original version, that was not the case. I guess I have to wait for new events and districts to see the new cutscenes.

P5 Royal Street Chatter.
Street chatter looks about the same.
Ryuji Sakamoto Expression.
Is this a new expression for Ryuji?
Kamoshida Palace Dungeon.
Dungeon of Kamoshida’s Palace looks great as usual. But there doesn’t seem to be any additional content, yet.

“Verdict”

So far, I’m in no way bored by P5 Royal. While most of what I’ve played after two hours doesn’t contain anything markedly new, I enjoyed the updated graphics. As a big fan of the P5 open-world, I’m also looking forward to exploring the new area of Kichijoji. Incidently, Kichijoji was the first area in Shin Megami Tensei (1993). I’ve never been there in person but as a Megaten fan, the area long feels “special” to me.

The flashy introduction of one of the new characters during the opening casino sequence was also very attention-grabbing. I’m definitely intrigued by the question: who on earth is this girl? More importantly, will I still choose Makoto as my waifu with this character in the picture?!

The above considered, well, I wouldn’t hide that my interest is waning with every fight. After all, I did play the original game twice, clocking near 150 hours in those two adventures.

For me to really dive into the game, the additional features have to come in quick. So far, they look to be rolling in smoothly, new music and graphics and gameplay and all. Would the P5 Royal thus end up being an even bigger hit than P5? The way P3: FES was?

At the moment, I believe this will be so.

Update: April 16, 2020

I haven’t much chance, or mood, to fully delve into the game. But since the above post, my experience with P5 Royal have uniformly been positively.

1. I Gave My Memory Too Much Credit

I thought I remember the game well but that turned out to hardly be the case. Unsure whether dialogues have been reworked or improved, but whatever I’ve read to date felt fresh and hilarious. At the moment, I’ve really looking forward to revisiting all of these “exchanges.”

Persona 5 Royal Buffet Scene.
The hilarious buffet scene after the completion of Kamoshida’s Palace.

2. Jose Is Adorable. But Mementos Is Still …

Jose, the new NPC, is as adorable as they come. His shop screen is also breathtakingly beautiful. Man, if I had a son, I would surely paint his bedroom that way.

On the other hand, Mementos is still … … I know a lot of effort had been taken to make it less dreary. Sadly, it still feels like a drag. I’m still rushing to reach the end-areas to get the expeditions done and over with.

Jose's Shop in Mementos.
Isn’t this pretty?!? Look at all those stars!

3. Confidants Are Easier to Work On

Oh, this improvement is wonderful. Confidants will call you after a meeting i.e. you another go at a boost. The awkward social creature I am, as in I always tend to pick the worst responses, these calls are invaluable in boosting my arcana. Great change, Atlus!

Ryuji Sakamoto and Ren Amamiya.
I’m still spending too much time with my Bro Ryuji. But there are fewer consequences now.

4. Thieves’ Den!!!!

This is a sly improvement, one that comes with an oh-so-lush Bossa Nova soundtrack. One look and I knew right away it was Atlus’ way to get players to obsess over trophies too.

“Trophies” in the form of unlockables. The more you play, the more you “complete,” the more things you can stuff into this den. Including very Daz3D like models of enemies, the Metaverse, Tokyo, etc. (Would the fishing spots be available?)

Persona 5 Royal Thieves Den.
The Thieves Den has enough content to befit a DLC. Including a pretty complicated card game.
Summary
Persona 5 Royal: Is This Enhanced Version of P5 Worth Playing?
Article Name
Persona 5 Royal: Is This Enhanced Version of P5 Worth Playing?
Description
How “fresh” is Persona 5 Royal for someone who has devoted over a hundred hours to the original 2017 game?
Author
Scribbling Geek
the authorScribbling Geek
The geek divides his free time between video games, movies, anime, and attempting to write decent short stories. Oh, and trying not to sprain his fingers from playing demisemiquavers on his Electone.

Thanks for commenting!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: